On October 2nd-4th, eleven St. Mark members - Dulcie Kugelman, Sally Morales and Jessica Burpee, John and Linda Benner, Craig and Joann Schaum, Judith Hug, Sue-Ann Wichman, Karen Speros, and I - took a trip to the US/Mexico border with the organization CIEL, the Center for International Experiential Learning. Our aim was to hear from as many perspectives as possible in order to have a more informed understanding of the challenges regarding immigration and asylum as they pertain to the US southern border. I gave an overview of that trip on October 16, which you can read here. I also invited attendees of the trip to share their thoughts and impressions, which you will find below.
1. We had been hearing countless horror stories about conditions at the US Mexican border, so we wanted to see with our own eyes if the stories were real. We found that, if anything, they were at least as bad as we had heard. And it looks like the only way that they will get better is for the US Congress to establish a reasonable program that doesn’t change every six months to two years. Unfortunately, that doesn’t seem to be about to happen. But we had to do something that might relieve some of the border turmoil. So we have joined forces with a small group of folks who are trying to relieve some of the angst in the lives of non-citizen service men who served in US armed forces and have been deported afterword because they missed out on being granted US Citizenship prior to their discharge for some administrative reasons. We feel we must at a minimum get them eligible for their deserved medical benefits. The group has made some progress to date and looks forward to making more!
2. My main reaction was that I gained a better understanding the complexity of the Border Issues and the significant challenges to finding solutions. Secondly, I was moved by the people we met who saw needs and went to work to do whatever they could. I don’t think they have any grand illusions of solving the problem, but rather are just trying to ease the burden of those impacted.
My perspective on seeking solutions is that:
- There is a need for border security, which now seems to be pretty robust due to technology advances and the wall (which seems to be a visual statement well beyond anything that is necessary).
- An Asylum process needs to be established. I was surprised to learn of the weak legal definitions and historical chaos of the process.
- A worker visa program should be something that could be agreed upon and provide some basic standards for the treatment of workers while providing legal status while under the program
- A pathway to citizenship needs to be instituted for the undocumented currently in the US. This should be the most immediate priority and could be politically possible in the aftermath of ICE excesses.
·
The people we met was the most impressive part of the trip. Individuals like Pedro Rios, with the American Friends Service Committee, who are seeking solutions, dealing with the political challenges on both sides of the border, and staying in the fight for their lifetimes.
Others who are not seeking grand solutions but just demonstrating care and dedication. I was most impressed by Pastor Gustavo Banda and his shelter with no employees (just volunteers and residents) who created a small miracle of the largest shelter in Mexico. It is a “build it and they will come” story. Here is a YouTube link.
3. I’d like to participate in creating part of a tapestry of our groups’ experiences at the border by sharing some details of what I learned concerning the role of the Customs and Border Patrol Agents (CBP), with whom we spent Friday morning.
At 9:00 A.M. we arrived in a pleasant assembly room at the San Diego Sector of the CBP for a “Public Affairs Briefing”. Following the briefing, we would accompany the morning speakers to the wall itself to observe it and the reasons it is effective.
The 3 speakers were men in their probable 40s and 50s, They were well groomed, congenial and wore gray/green cargo pants, matching button-up shirts with collars, a side arm, a clearly displayed US Customs and Border Patrol Patch, and a name badge. “We are Not Ice” stated Agent Eric, early in his remarks. “But these days, we can be authorized to help them out if they need us”. Each man introduced himself by offering his record as a long time Customs and Border Patrol Agent, who had worked for several administrations with a variety of policies. “Ask us any questions you like” offered the principal speaker for the morning, Agent Eric. “But I will not discuss politics. Our agency serves whatever administration is in place.”
We watch a PR film which made the following points:
· Customs and Border Protection is an agency of DHS as of 2003, though border security agencies have existed for much longer in the U.S
· Its mission is reducing the likelihood that dangerous people and capabilities enter the United States between the 7 ports of land entry on the southern border.
· CA Border Patrol Agents do not arrest anyone. Rather, they apprehend those crossing illegally and deliver them to the nearest legal entry point, where (at least in theory) they are allowed to request legal entry from a different arm of the CBP, Immigration officers who control immigration, customs and agricultural products.
4. Having the opportunity to participate in the CIEL Trip to the U.S.-Mexico border was incredibly impactful. The experience put a human face on an issue that is often dehumanized, politicized, and used for secondary gain. Through meeting and speaking directly with individuals whose lives are impacted, we were humbled and reminded of the very real human experience at the heart of it all.
Of all the experiences on this trip, visiting Una Luz De Esperanza Por Amor De Dio, a shelter for repatriated citizens in Tijuana, was the most impactful to us. It brought the human heart of the U.S./Mexico deportation issue into focus—not through politics or policies, but through the lives of the people directly affected. People arriving in Mexico after being deported from the United States, often with nothing and nowhere to turn. Families displaced, children separated from parents, and lives suddenly torn apart. Seeing this reality for people was defeating.
However, God finds a way to be with and protect His people. What moved us the most was learning that one woman saw this need and decided to do something about it. She opened her doors to families with nowhere else to go, creating a place of safety, dignity, compassion, and community when so much has been taken from them.
One significant takeaway from this experience was that even in the devastation and heartbreak created by displacement, there is hope in humanity. When systems and governments leave people without the resources or support they desperately need, there are individuals who step forward, open their hearts, and build a community that cares for one another. One woman cannot solve the crisis, but she can change countless lives, one person and one family at a time.
No comments:
Post a Comment